Real-time collaboration and audio (Liveblocks & Livekit)
with David Mytton & Jean Yang
Liveblocks (real-time collaboration API) & Livekit (open source live video and audio API), a devtools discussion with David Mytton and Jean Yang.
Episode 4 of the Console Devtools Podcast, a devtools discussion with David Mytton (Co-founder, Console) and Jean Yang (CEO, Akita Software).
Other things mentioned:
- Zoom Bachelor.
- Open Broadcaster Software.
- A16Z - The Cost of Cloud.
David: Welcome to the Console Devtools tools podcast, a show all about interesting developer tools. I'm David Mytton, co-founder of Console.
Jean: I'm Jean Yang, CEO of Akita software and API Observability startup. In each episode, we'll discuss two interesting developer tools. We're keeping this to 15 minutes so let's get started.
David: Our first tool this week is Liveblocks. This is a real-time collaboration API. Before we get into that, I need to say Console is an investor in Liveblocks. We've started making some angel investments into devtools companies that we come across and we apply the same strict selection criteria for our newsletter, which means we're only investing in tools that we'd also recommend in the newsletter. If you're building something interesting and are fundraising, then definitely get in touch.
Liveblocks makes it really easy to drop in live presence into your app. They have a range of different components that can be used with react or node packages and allows you to build in live courses, chat, and reactions. If you've used Figma, then you know what that functionality is and it makes it really easy to deal with the networking performance and just the presence detection across multiple places.
Jean: I thought this was a super cool product. I love seeing the rise of APIs for everything, because what this means is that developers just have way more power at their fingertips. I agree that it makes much more sense to buy these days.
I'll tell a story about when I realized just the power of all the APIs that exist. When I was in college and people had hackathons, at the end, you had maybe a single page website or something like that. A few years ago, I judged a college hackathon back when I was a professor. By the end of the weekend, people had these crazy apps that talk to your bank account. You could listen to different music as you're walking around a room because they were using the mapping API and some music API.
I just feel like making real-time collaboration, something that's easily accessible is something inevitable. Some company's going to do it. I think the question is it Liveblocks or is it someone else? And so I think being first definitely has some advantages.
I couldn't really tell with Liveblocks because I feel like the docs were a little bit sparse still and I didn't have a chance to build a whole app up, but I think there is some set of primitives for real-time collaboration and whoever gets it right is going to make a big impact. I'm not sure if the impact is financially positive as something like Stripe, which is payments, but just what it can enable, there's no real-time video editing right now. There's no real time shopping list editing right now.
I'd love to see real-time editing in more apps. It seems like it shouldn't be too hard to support mobile on this, but I think being able to real-time edit things on the phone is really where it’s going to be really, really powerful.
David: We've seen how hard it is to build this kind of real-time collaboration and tabs because Microsoft Office still doesn't get to the level that Google docs gets to. Just seeing the cursors move around and conflict free editing just seems to be really difficult. What it comes down to, is this a niche product? What kind of products do we think might build live collaboration and in real time?
Jean: And how specific is it to the product? Is it possible to factor out the primitives? Because if you're real-time editing a video, where the cursors are might not matter. It's where the time bar is, but can you flatten that into a single primitive? If you're real-time collaborating on a game, if you're playing a game on teams, maybe it's different things you want to share. So, I'm super curious. I think, I think this'll be an interesting product because as the scope of what people implement real-time. As collaboration grows, I think the primitives will solidify, but I don't know how that process would look with someone putting an API product out there.
David: Just having the APIs available to drop in means there'll be a lot more experimentation. Whether it's live gaming or we've seen apps during the pandemic, to sit around with your friends remotely and stream Netflix and watch live events, just because you can't do that anymore. I think the removal of constraints, as well as the addition of constraints that we've had in the pandemic is a really good way of stimulating innovation.
Jean: I think there's a lot more remote work now. What if there were more different kinds of pair programming apps? I think virtual collaboration is really the future. Having other apps, being able to get to the point of Google docs would be awesome.
David: How extreme could we get with building this collaboration functionality into apps? I can certainly think back when I was on call and responding to incidents with servers, just having the ability to spin up a war room and get your team together, collaborating and over a terminal to see what people are typing in. You've often got a log that when you're responding so you can coordinate long running incidents and building those kinds of things into security response might also be interesting if you've got a team of people; particularly if they're distributed, collaborating on responding to a critical security bug.
Jean: Even when we respond to users right now, because we're not in the same room, we have to do this handshake over Slack. You can imagine if there was an app for immediately responding to user tickets, collaboratively and integrated into Slack. A lot of how we do our remote meetings is with a Notion doc. Notion actually isn't super real-time and you don't see exactly where people's cursors are. It's a little bit there, but even Notion doesn't quite have that there yet. But I think having more presence indicators could be really interesting.
Jean: Yeah. WebRTC is super hard. I haven't done a lot of programming with video myself, but over the pandemic I became one of the first users of this tool called ohyay. It is a creator platform that lets you make any kind of browser-based video experience you want. I had accidentally become a video producer during lockdown because I accidentally first became a matchmaker with my Jean Date program. Then, that led to me producing a couple of video shows, doing Bachelorette in Zoom Bachelor.
But before Zoom Bachelor, this team pitched me on, "Hey, do you want to be the first public use of ohyay?" Their pitch was, "Well, because we're a creator platform, we can help you basically set up the scenes for Zoom Bachelor and easily script the scene transitions. You could lay out the video feeds however you want, overlay graphics very easily." It's browser-based Open Broadcast Software (OBS) that's scriptable scene to scene. Maybe OBS does that too, but OBS is really hard to use.
It was really interesting because often I got to see under the hood because it was a very early beta product at the time. It seems like WebRTC allows for a ton of stuff. I believe that browser-based video is the way of the future. It's so easy. Anyone can do it. I think, especially with everything moving more remote now, or people realizing the power of remote even for a non-pandemic era.
There are limitations, and the team building this has had decades of experience in video and still they got tripped up sometimes. Making this available to large numbers of programmers, I think is awesome because there's just so much we can support creatively.
David: Definitely an interesting trend with startups forming around rebuilding popular software as a service in APIs. LiveKit is essentially Twilio or Agora but just for video and audio, and open source. We know how popular Agora is because it's powering Clubhouse, which has boomed over the last 12 months. Just being able to drop these components into your app, like with Liveblocks, removes all those barriers.
I'm interested to see if performance becomes a problem. We discussed on the last episode with Tuple how they actually implemented that video layer in C++ as a foundation and then built the UI on top of that so that they could get better performance. They were really going for high resolution screen sharing, which is quite a different use case from just video and audio. Just being able to drop this technology into any app and have it work and be open source is quite compelling.
Jean: I'm curious if people will start out using this and then rip it out after some point and build their own and what the line is there. Even for existing SasS tools, I talked with companies who say, "Well, we're trying to rip out Splunk because it's too expensive. We're trying to rip out some pretty core technologies and build it ourselves." These are companies that are quite big, often post-IPO. But if you're a tiny game company that's trying to embed video feeds, does it become mission critical to have to rip out the video layer yourself very early on? I think that's a really interesting question.
David: I think that's a big problem with SaaS pricing is that as you scale, you just end up spending huge amounts of money. There's a really interesting Andreessen Horowitz blog post about looking into the true cost of cloud for some of the big public SaaS companies. The beauty of open source is that you can just run it all yourself when you get too big for the SaaS pricing. But then the benefit of SaaS is you can just hand off all of the scaling to that provider. You don't have to deal with it.
Jean: I think there's going to be some really interesting shifts in what people are able to build and how they choose to go about scaling it I can't predict. It'll be really interesting to see.
David: What kind of apps do you think might benefit from adding a live video and audio? Certainly Google Docs, that doesn't exist unless you're trying to cast a tab to a Google Meet screen-share.
Jean: I think everything. At my team, we sit in a virtual office all day and anything we work on collaboratively together is actually an embedded video. A screen share stream in our virtual office. You can turn video and audio on and off. It's not that everyone's streaming their video all day, but there's been some really interesting things we've been able to do just virtually by having completely configurable video feeds. We're using this platform ohyay, so everyone got to set up their offices how they wanted.
We could set up our conference rooms however we wanted. We have a plant conservatory where we're experimenting with people who go there if they want to work in the same room with video on for some period of time. We do most things with video now because we're an all-remote team. If we're working on a Notion doc together synchronously, we'll get into the same room, share our videos at the same time as working on the Notion doc, same with the Google doc. It’s the same if we're resolving a user request or an incident, we get in the same room.
I think video's super high signal. I think it should be there all the time. I also have an ohyay space with my friends that we just hang out in. For a while, during the height of the lockdown, we would just kind of say, "Hey, let's hang out in this space from this hour." So that hour, this day, people would file in and out. It was super fun. I think that a lot of my life over lockdown has been like a personal Clubhouse but with video. To me, video is a much more fun and low emotional energy channel than audio.
David: We’re certainly getting there with audio. I think every app that I can think of is now adding it in, trying to copy Clubhouse. Even Slack was bugging me the other day to suddenly turn on audio rooms and it's trying to copy Discord. I suppose, where people just drop into the room when they're playing games. Being able to upgrade that to video just seems like an easy option that people should be able to enable.
Jean: Our team had tried Discord before with the audio rooms and audio seemed to be something active to indicate presence, whereas for video, you just have to sit there. I think video is going to be the presence indicator of the future. If you're not going there to actively hang out and you're just trying to get a sense of presence. I think, video everywhere is really the way to go.
Something cool ohyay had for a while, was that you could just emoji the video of yourself and do things. You can imagine a presence indicator on a Google Doc being not just a cursor, but a little video feed. Is this person actively working on this? Are they working on something else? Is their video switched off? Videos are super interesting, and a low effort, high signal indicator.
David: Since the idea of trying to replace the presence of being in an office, where everyone is just there and they're working, with video I think there's going to be some interesting privacy challenges. Making sure you do know when your video is on or off and you want that the little light on your laptop showing when the video is recording.
Jean: You can imagine if you're working on something over the phone with someone, which doesn't really happen right now, because we don't have very good real-time collaboration with the phone; but you can imagine this working for games with friends. If you and your friend are shopping for something together because you're going to meet up, but you're in different locations right now. They can see what you're doing. You can see what they're doing. Video just gives you a way to not have to talk.
David: Alright, well that's it for this week. Please let us know what you think on Twitter or by email. I'm @davidmytton on Twitter and links are in the show notes. Don't forget to subscribe to the weekly Devtools newsletter at console.dev.
Jean: I am @jeanqasaur on Twitter with a Q. You can also follow Akita Software, @AkitaSoftware for the latest in API observability, understanding your systems from the outside. And I will see you next week.
David: See you next week.
Console is the place developers go to find the best tools. Each week, our weekly newsletter picks out the most interesting tools and new releases. We keep track of everything - dev tools, devops, cloud, and APIs - so you don't have to.